Patricio Cea Charbin

University of California, San Diego · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Political Economy

Job market paper

Cleavages, Political Parties, and Polarization

Why do some societies become more politically polarized and susceptible to populism? In this paper, I explore the hypothesis that these processes depend on how political parties respond to recent drivers within patterns of political competition that developed much earlier. Foundational political science theories argued that the dimensions along which political parties compete often originate in major conflicts that occurred in the period leading up to the emergence of mass politics. The societal divisions triggered by these conflicts became politically organized and shaped the creation of the modern party system, influencing political competition over the long run. I focus on the Carlist Wars (1833–1876) in Spain as an example of such conflicts and estimate their political effects using an instrumental variable exploiting variation in wartime logistical conditions combined with a novel dataset spanning three centuries to trace these effects over time. I find that areas more exposed to the wars exhibit lower political polarization today and weaker support for parties using populist rhetoric. Evidence on mechanisms suggests that the Carlist Wars helped form an additional axis of political competition that, insofar as it does not overlap strongly with the left-right divide, reduces incentives to intensify political polarization and weakens the conditions populist leaders often exploit. The findings remain after including a rich set of controls, and are not explained by the leading alternative hypotheses. Violations of the exclusion restriction would need to account for around 60% to 90% of the reduced-form effects to explain away the results, while placebo tests provide no evidence that the empirical strategy captures confounding factors. The results shed light on the role of historically rooted structures of political competition in shaping societies’ susceptibility to polarization and populism.