Torsha Chakravorty

University of California, San Diego · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Development, Public, Econometrics

Job market paper

State Capacity, Brokers, and Service Delivery

Social protection programs are central to people’s lives. However, administrative burdens in accessing them create informal markets for brokers who help applicants navigate the process for a fee. Whether these brokers substitute for public capacity or complement it remains unclear. We study this question using a reform in an Indian state that expanded staffing at public service centers to help citizens submit applications, without increasing the number of officials deciding whether to approve them. Using pre-existing differences in district exposure to the reform, we find that a 1 percent increase in staffing raises broker-mediated applications by 1.7 percent, compared to 1.1 percent for direct applications. Yet direct applications become faster, reducing brokers’ average speed advantage. These patterns rule out a model where public workers purely substitute for brokers and, under maintained assumptions, one where brokers only obtain priority through speed money. A model where public workers make brokers more productive can explain joint results. Our findings highlight the role of informal markets in building state capacity.