Vafa Behnam

University of California, San Diego · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

International, Development, Macroeconomics, Economic History

Job market paper

When Does Trade Protection Help? Evidence from the Rise of American Manufacturing

Does trade protection slow or boost growth? I study this question in the context of US industrialization in the 19th century. I develop a novel empirical design leveraging differential county exposure to nationwide tariffs based on distance to international ports, using newly digitized tariff, import price and railway freight data. Exploiting a nationwide fiscal shock that suddenly raised tariffs for reasons unrelated to local industry conditions, I find protection reduces output growth for products near the technological frontier but boosts growth for those far behind. I also find protection shifts patent activity towards far-from-frontier products, suggesting a reshaping of comparative advantage. A model of trade and innovation with variable markups generates these results: protection enables a far-from-frontier producer to capture the rents from innovating, while a close-to-frontier producer's high market share and low residual demand elasticity mean protection reduces the gain from innovating. This model provides an imperfect competition rationale for infant industry protection distinct from the usual learning-by-doing justification. I conclude by studying the welfare effects of trade, which can be negative unlike in workhorse trade models.