Website CV Paper
Fields
Econometrics, Macroeconomics
Job market paper
When the News Matters: Newspaper Text and Real-Time Forecasts of U.S. Growth
Does newspaper text help to forecast the U.S. economy in real time, and when? I build monthly text series, topic shares, policy-uncertainty counts and sentiment, from 11.76 million articles of seven U.S. newspapers over 1990–2020, and race them against 101 FRED-MD series in unrestricted MIDAS regressions estimated with four machine-learning methods on expanding real-time windows, scored as RMSE relative to an autoregression over 2003Q1–2020Q1. First, on all articles text alone is behind the hard data for GDP at the nowcast and for investment, and adding it to the hard data with the method held fixed gives 14 significant improvements and 7 deteriorations in 144 comparisons, about 7 of each being expected by chance; the improvements are for consumption. Second, which articles are used matters: an automatic filter for the economic articles, checked against hand labels, improves the text forecasts in 27 of 144 comparisons and worsens them in 4, in normal times as well as in the recession, under every selection rule tried. Third, the gain over the benchmark is a matter of timing: four quarters of 2008–2009 hold between a third and a half of the benchmark's squared error; in those quarters text beats the benchmark by 10–13% for GDP and 20–35% for consumption, and outside them neither text nor hard data beat it. The same-method gain from adding text survives scoring against first releases; the gain over the benchmark at the nowcast does not.