Sara Canilang

University of Minnesota · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Finance, Labor, Applied Micro

Job market paper

The Consequences of Debt and the Tradeoff of Bankruptcy

Bankruptcy is designed as a race-neutral financial fresh start, yet significant racial disparities persist in debt relief outcomes. Black households are more likely to file for bankruptcy. Among filers, they are more likely to file the harder and less successful Chapter 13, a 3-to-5 year repayment plan, over the quicker and highly successful Chapter 7, and less likely to complete their plans, even at the same income, assets, and debt. Even when their case is successful, Black filers leave with more debt, since they owe more nondischargeable debt, mostly student loans. Black households are also sued more for unpaid debt, which can lead to wage garnishment and drive bankruptcy filings. This paper asks: how does bankruptcy law translate racial gaps in household finances and debt collection into disparities in debt relief? Using a new dataset of detailed bankruptcy case records, I develop a structural lifecycle model with endogenous bankruptcy chapter choice, default, and repayment with plan dismissal and wage garnishment risk. The model incorporates institutional features including fee structure, repayment plan design, dischargeability rules, and wage garnishment exposure. These features interact with racial differences in household finances, including differences in liquidity, assets, debt composition, and income. Without targeting any racial moment, the model reproduces the direction of the chapter filing gap, with more Black households filing Chapter 13 even though they are more likely to be eligible for Chapter 7, because of the upfront Chapter 7 fee. Removing the upfront Chapter 7 fee requirement reverses the racial gap in chapter choice, a 12 percentage point swing that is about 40% of the gap in the data. Fewer Chapter 13 plans fail, and the share of cases that end in a discharge rises from 76% to 83%, and from 73% to 85% for Black filers. Making student loans dischargeable nearly closes the racial gap in how much debt Chapter 7 discharges, but the upfront fee still limits how many Black households can take advantage of it.