Website CV Paper
Fields
Labor, Behavioral & Experimental, Health
Job market paper
Fickle Discrimination: Evidence from Emergency Triage
Discrimination is usually attributed to decision-makers' stable beliefs and preferences. I show that persistent and consequential discrimination can also be driven by a more fickle process: transitory and irrelevant features of the decision context sharply increase or decrease disparities produced by the same decision-maker from one moment to the next. In 1.9 million emergency department triage decisions, non-white patients are 6 percentage points (21%) less likely than observably identical white patients to receive top priority from the same nurse in the same shift. Exploiting quasi-random patient arrivals and nurse assignment, I find that the racial triage gap widens by 27% immediately after encounters with familiar, lower-risk frequent emergency department users, most of whom are non-white. This increase masks opposite responses by frequent-user race: the gap widens after non-white frequent users (+43%) but narrows after white ones (-20%). The racial triage gap moves in the same directions with longer-run exposure, reversing against white patients after enough exposure to white frequent users. Time pressure leads nurses to collect less patient information and respond nearly twice as strongly to frequent-user encounters. These results cannot be explained by standard statistical learning but point to nurses assessing patients by coarse racial similarity to prior lower-risk cases, particularly when rushed. This fickle discrimination pushes triage away from a race-blind machine-learning benchmark and carries into downstream care, including hospital admission. Removing frequent-user and time-pressure effects would shrink the overall racial triage gap by at least 28%. These findings suggest disparities are more malleable than previously believed and respond to how institutions allocate cases and time.