Website CV Paper
Fields
Theory, Behavioral & Experimental
Job market paper
Extracting Models from Data: A Cost-Benefit Framework
We develop a theoretical framework for analyzing how learning occurs directly from data in the absence of prior information. We interpret learning as the process through which decision makers identify a model, defined as the set of variables that matter for the outcome, and use those variables to form behavioral rules. Rule extraction reflects a trade-off between each rule's value and its complexity cost. The comparative statics show that extraction of the optimal rule depends not only on its own value, but also on how clearly it outperforms competing alternatives. Differences in cognitive costs then make agents respond differently to changes in relative rule values, generating systematic and predictable disagreement even when they face the same data. Finally, the framework makes rule-specific costs identifiable from behavior, allowing us to determine which objective measures of a rule's complexity can be interpreted as arguments of the cost function. We test the theory in our experiment and in a reanalysis of data from Kendall and Oprea (2024), finding strong support for its predictions in both settings.