Horia Guias

Universitat Pompeu Fabra · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Behavioral & Experimental, Industrial Organization, Environmental & Energy

Job market paper

Perceived Responsibility for Negative Externalities

Why do some individuals pay to offset their own emissions but not the same emissions caused by someone else? I study how previously caused harm and anticipated outcomes shape the perception of responsibility for negative externalities, and how that perception affects decision-making. In a theoretical framework, a decision maker can repair personally caused harm and exogenous background harm of unknown origin. Beyond outcome-based preferences, she cares about maintaining a moral self-image that is activated by backward-looking responsibility. Under certain conditions, a desire to restore that moral self-image overrides efficiency or equity concerns, leading the decision maker to repair exclusively personally caused harm while ignoring background harm. Based on this behavioural prediction, I propose a sharp revealed preference test that isolates responsibility-based preferences from outcome-based preferences. This informs the design of an online experiment in which I vary the causal history of harm, the price to repair personally caused harm, and the price to repair background harm. Structural estimation of preferences reveals considerable heterogeneity in the influence of perceived responsibility on behaviour both at the individual and aggregate level. Overall, subjects exhibit a responsibility premium of 29%--48% when paying to repair personally caused harm. These results have important implications for the limits of individual responsibility in consumer markets, the demand for voluntary carbon offsets, and the efficiency of CSR activities.