Camille Wixon

University of Virginia · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Health, Industrial Organization, Labor

Job market paper

The Price of Permanence: A Study of Household Contraceptive Choice including Sterilization

In 2015–2017, 17% of women aged 20–45 relied on female sterilization for contraception, compared with 5% who relied on a partner’s vasectomy. The Affordable Care Act’s contraceptive mandate requires coverage of female sterilization but imposes no equivalent requirement for vasectomies, leaving households facing substantial out-of-pocket costs. Motivated by this policy asymmetry, this paper estimates household contraceptive demand using a nested logit model and MarketScan claims data on approximately 14.2 million observations from 2015-2017. Estimates reveal a strong aversion to permanent contraception, but a preference for male sterilization, with households indifferent between paying $346 for a vasectomy and female sterilization at zero cost, holding other characteristics constant. Consistent with differences within couples in preferences for the male contraceptive method, I find the valuation of vasectomy increases by $85 with each standard-deviation increase in a proxy for female bargaining power. Eliminating out-of-pocket costs for vasectomy increases predicted annual uptake 87 percent from 1.58 to 2.95 percent, increasing overall contraceptive use by 1.26 percent, as some additional vasectomies substitute for existing methods. These findings carry implications for contraceptive coverage policy, suggesting that eliminating vasectomy cost sharing can increase permanent contraceptive adoption while reducing the financial and medical burdens associated with sterilization.