Jan Philip Steitz

University of Wisconsin Milwaukee · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Public, Labor, Economic History

Job market paper

Raise Fast, Cut Slow: Asymmetric Reversal of Recession-Driven State Tax Increases

Under balanced-budget rules a recession should force states to adjust their tax rates, yet the most comprehensive study of state tax changes to date finds no effect of recessions on rate levels. I document a clear short-run response followed by faster and more frequent reversal, which narrows that puzzle without dissolving it. Using a panel of 50 U.S. states from 1960 to 2022, I show that recessions raise the probability of any major state tax increase by 7.7 percentage points while recoveries produce no offsetting cuts within three years. A formal test rejects equality of the recession increase and decrease responses at the 1% level, and rejects at the 5% level the equality of the recession increase and recovery decrease coefficients. Those increases are then cut sooner and more often, facing more than twice the hazard of a subsequent cut, and 28 percent survive a decade uncut against 62 percent of increases enacted in normal times. Completeness differs at five years but not detectably at ten, and the median increase of either kind still stands in full after a decade, so substantial rate persistence remains. The asymmetry is clearest in the timing and incidence of cuts rather than in how far they go. Separately, cumulative recession exposure is not associated with higher rate levels. Together these weigh against a permanent upward ratchet, though neither establishes that the subsequent cuts account for the absence of accumulation. The contemporaneous differential is a within-state gap between recession and other years, at 0.67 percentage points on the top income rate, rather than an accumulated stock.