Masahiro Nishida

University of Wisconsin-Madison · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Industrial Organization, Applied Micro, Innovation

Job market paper

Product-Harm Crises and Intermediaries in the Used Car Market

Product-harm crises, such as recalls and scandals, have been studied as negative information shocks about product quality. In used car markets, such a shock reaches households through dealers, which choose not only the retail price of an affected car but also whether to sell it to a household or to another dealer at wholesale, where the price of an unsold car feeds back into retail prices. This paper asks how dealers adjust the prices of affected cars, how household purchases respond, and how these responses would change if interdealer trade were restricted. Focusing on Mitsubishi Motors' 2016 fuel economy scandal in Japan as a demand shock, I use wholesale auction records and online retail listings to compare the affected models that Mitsubishi built for Nissan with unaffected cars of other manufacturers before and after the disclosure. Prices of affected cars fell in both markets, at retail by less at Nissan-affiliated dealers than at independent dealers, whereas the probability of a sale to a household rose only briefly. To measure the long-run effect of the scandal and the consequences of restricting interdealer trade, I estimate an overlapping-generations model in which dealers of different types, each a local monopolist at retail, trade with one another at wholesale, sell to households, and resell unsold cars at wholesale. The estimated loss in households' valuation of affected cars is larger at independent dealers than at Nissan-affiliated dealers. In counterfactuals that segment the wholesale market by dealer type or require dealers to sell their trade-ins at retail, the gap between the retail price responses of the two dealer types widens, because the interdealer market no longer pools the two losses into a single wholesale price or lets dealers offload unwanted cars rather than discount them.