Nicolò Generoso

Yale University · Economics · 2026–27 job market

Fields

Industrial Organization

Job market paper

Universal Healthcare with a Private Option: Investment and Congestion in Diagnostic Imaging

We study patient welfare, capacity investment, and wait times in a universal healthcare system where patients can either wait for publicly funded care or pay for faster private treatment. Allowing private-pay care can stimulate capacity investment and relieve public queues, but market power can distort prices and the allocation of treatment. We build a model of patient choice, wait times, pricing, and capacity investment. Estimation combines administrative data on publicly funded care and scraped private prices and appointment availability. We find that patients have heterogeneous preferences for timely care. Moreover, pricing and capacity choices affect equilibrium wait times, but profit-maximizing providers do not internalize the resulting congestion externality. The socially efficient allocation would lower private prices and expand capacity. Disallowing private-pay care would reduce patient welfare through the loss of sorting on willingness to pay for timeliness, increased congestion in public queues, and reduced capacity investment. Attaining the status quo welfare under public-only provision would require a 35%-higher public budget to fund additional publicly provided capacity. Private-pay care benefits patients in nearly all urgency, age, and income groups, including those unlikely to use it themselves, who gain from reduced congestion in public queues.