Website CV Paper
Fields
Labor, Industrial Organization, Public
Job market paper
Academic Match and the Returns to For-Profit and Public Colleges
Short vocational college programs can deliver substantial returns. Public subsidies for these programs are concentrated in community colleges (CCs). Yet CCs graduate only 30% of their students, while two-year for-profit alternatives graduate twice that share. Using administrative records covering nearly all two-year for-profit and public college students in Texas, I use distance instruments to identify college sector effects among students on the for-profit/public margin. For-profits raise long-run completion rates by 32 percentage points, with effects largest among the weakest students. Despite for-profits' higher graduation rates, a within-individual design shows that their degrees yield long-run returns comparable to those of CCs. Expected returns at enrollment exhibit substantial match effects: academically weak students gain more from for-profits because of elevated dropout risk at CCs, while the strongest students earn higher returns from CCs, partly due to the option value of academic and four-year pathways. To better understand mechanisms, I assemble new program-level data on course requirements. For-profit programs require significantly less academic coursework, helping rationalize their comparative advantage for academically weaker students. Finally, I estimate the welfare effects of extending subsidies to for-profits. Accounting for fiscal savings on substitution out of CCs and increased tax revenues, I find the subsidy expansion is self-financing and generates substantial earnings gains.