Website CV Paper
Fields
Macroeconomics, Environmental & Energy, International
Job market paper
Make or buy? Allocative energy efficiency in production networks
Firms differ vastly in the energy they need to produce the same input, so the aggregate energy used in a supply chain depends on which producer is selected at each step. We show that, when energy prices do not reflect the social cost of emissions, they distort this selection, generating a new extensive margin of energy-use misallocation across producers. Quantifying this margin requires accounting for in-house production, since the actual producer of an input may be the buyer itself and a firm’s observed energy intensity reflects both its energy efficiency and the energy requirements of the inputs it makes itself. We embed a model of make-or-buy decisions in a sequential production network calibrated to Italian firm-to-firm transaction data and develop a method to infer each firm’s unobserved in-house input set from observed transactions. Comparing actual to potential producers, we document widespread energy efficiency gaps: for most inputs, a more energy-efficient producer is available. Many of these gaps are justified by differences in relationship-specific gains from outsourcing, but correcting those that are not cuts the energy needed per unit of output by 12%, a fifth of the reduction achieved by optimal carbon pricing, and accounts for around a tenth of its welfare gains. Switching between making and buying inputs delivers more than half of these savings.