Website CV Paper
Fields
Public, Finance, Macroeconomics
Job market paper
The Untaxables? Effective Capital Gains Taxes with Diversified Portfolios
Capital gains are central to the taxation of the very rich, yet realization taxes allow investors to defer payment. Despite its policy relevance, a measure of long-run effective taxation capturing optimal deferral has been missing because of technical challenges. I close this gap with a model that represents portfolios by distributions of embedded gains and losses. It describes a dynamic trading problem in which today’s sales change tomorrow’s tax opportunities. I establish when harvesting losses and selling the least appreciated positions is optimal over any horizon. Aggregate downside risk can reverse this rule. I express the consumption benefits of tax-optimal trading as effective tax rates and equivalent returns. The calibration matches historical U.S. market conditions and the OECD average capital gains tax rate. A 25% tax on realized gains and dividends sustains the same consumption perpetuity as an accrual tax of about 14%. The corresponding return premium is 74 basis points: at 25%, an accrual-taxed portfolio needs this additional expected annual return to match consumption under realization taxes. A cohort-model extension with carry-over basis at death predicts that revenue under realization taxes is 49% lower than under accrual taxes. Continued deferral thus limits the revenue and progressivity of realization-based capital gains taxes.