Website CV Paper
Fields
Behavioral & Experimental, Labor, Education
Job market paper
Making a Difference? The Role of Social Impact in College Major Choice
Work is not only a means of earning a living, it can also be a source of meaning through the contribution people feel they make to society. Because the choice of academic major largely shapes future career paths, we ask: do students hold accurate perceptions of how fulfilling different fields are in terms of social impact, and how do these perceptions shape major choices? We address these questions through a survey experiment at a large U.S. public university. We find that students substantially underestimate how satisfied previous graduates report being with their contribution, with significant heterogeneity in the extent of underestimation by field. These beliefs are consistent with stereotyping: students believe that graduates in fields such as Health and Social Sciences are much more likely to be satisfied with their contribution than graduates in Physics & Mathematics or Computer Science, while nationally representative data on college graduates shows the gap is much smaller. We show that randomly providing information on previous graduates' experiences of impact across all fields significantly shifts students' perceptions, with revisions proportional to their initial misperceptions. These revised beliefs lead students who value social contribution to recommend a broader set of majors to like-minded peers. We see more limited effects on students' intentions and class enrollment, with significant changes in intentions only among women, who value social impact most and shift toward fields whose social impact they had underestimated.